Skip to main content

The Sign of the Mermaid Bookstore

John King Books, like most reputable book stores, has free book racks in the atrium of their colossal warehouse. After I purchased my ephemera I partook of the offer to take as many free books as I wished.

Within the books The King's Minion by Rafael Sabatini (1930) and Treading the Winepress by Ralph Connor (1925) was the book trade label "The Sign of the Mermaid". 

Intrigued, I did some research. It traces to a bookshop at 1014 E. Jefferson Avenue of Detroit. The book store by that same name opened around October 23, 1925 and was operated by Doris McMillan Pittman (later Hoover), granddaughter of Senator James McMillan, in the converted home of her late father William C. McMillan.

The Yale Alumni Weekly, October 23, 1925

Her initial business partners were E. Byrne Hackett, Phelps Newberry and Edwin K. Hoover (later her third husband). Newly graduated Yale alumnus Clayton Morse, Jr. was the manager. An article in The Yale Alumni Weekly from October 23, 1925 stated that he had "spent the summer in travel abroad. He visited a number of bookshops in England." Which is a curious statement since a 1982 article in the Grosse Pointe News, that recollected on the origins of the Grosse Pointe branch from its Detroit namesake, stated:

The sign of the Mermaid has had a fascinating evolution from a London book store to one of the Pointe's finest shops.

In the late 1800s a young English woman opened a bookshop in London, England and named it The Sign of the Mermaid. This name was chosen because it was well known that poets and writers, as well as assorted intellectuals, frequented the London tavern known as the Mermaid and often gathered under its sign in front, to discuss literary matters.

At the turn of the 20th century The Sign of the Mermaid was brought to Detroit as an elegant bookstore and located at 1014 Jefferson Avenue.

Could Morse have been the impetus for Doris's foray into the book world as a bored housewife? A 1974 Detroit Free Press article discussing the sale of the Grosse Pointe location, which Morse founded, states:

When the Morse family opened "The Mermaid" in 1938, it was a bookstore located on near East Jefferson Avenue in Detroit where socialite matrons and civic leaders would browse after lunch at the adjacent Stockholm restaurant.

Which is a bit of revisionist history that obliterates Doris McMillan's hand in the enterprise's founding.

Detroit Times, February 10, 1926
It was part of a group of shops that included fine furniture and masterworks of art. Newspaper clippings mention the works of Vermeer and others having been along the visiting gallery pieces.

Detroit Free Press, October 22, 1925
The store relocated to 17925 Kercheval Avenue, in Grosse Pointe in 1938, two years after her death.

During the Detroit tenure of the store, tragedy struck Mrs. Pittman as her young husband Steuart Pittman died on January 29, 1927 of Hodgkin's Disease. He was 39. Ironically, Doris would die exactly 9 years later at the same age and in the same house at 905 Three Mile Drive in Grosse Pointe.

On October 31, 1927 a Notice of Dissolution was filed on the Sign of the Mermaid with $50,000 capital. I would assume that this was a matter of settling Mr. Pittman's estate as the store seemingly continued with normal operations.

The Publishers Weekly, Volume 113, February 4, 1928

A year later on February 1, 1928 she opened a branch location at the Book Cadillac formerly occupied by an offshoot of Dennen's Bookshop.

Saginaw News, February 10, 1929
She then had an ill-fated marriage to her store manager Clayton Morse, Jr. Morse had come to Detroit from Stamford, Connecticut after their marriage in New York.

He also managed her Baltimore location which seemed to 

Detroit News, April 1, 1932
In a 1933 Detroit Times article about the divorce scandal which culminated in a domino effect, creating another divorce and marriage as Morse married the ex-wife of another Grosse Pointe socialite with whom he was apparently having an affair. The latter man, not to be outdone, picked up another wife as well. Only Doris was left by her lonesome. 

Detroit Times, October 4, 1933
As stated in the article below, "what had started as a hobby [the book store]..."ended as a slap." Whether this was a proverbial slap or a physical one has yet to be determined.

Doris's last attempt at love came two years before her death from heart failure when she married Edwin K. Hoover. He was the former chairman of the First Detroit Co and an initial investor in the $50,000 enterprise along with Doris and Phelps Newberry.

Furniture World, Volume 61, 1925
They resided in her familial home in Grosse Pointe.

Detroit Free Press, January 21, 1934
There is a write-up of the Grosse Pointe location from 1935 on this blog:

A second book shop is located in the Punch and Judy Theatre Building and is a branch of the ”Sign of the Mermaid” a book store in Detroit. Both this shop and the very inviting Florist shop next door, owned and operated by Arthur Passelk, are especially attractive and unique, having walls and ceilings of antique pine which gives a very home like appearance.

It also seems that Doris tried her hand at book publishing just before her death in 1935 with the release of Caviar to Cordial: A Book of Recipes by Eleanor and Vincent Dwyer. I have yet to delve into this matter so hopefully there will be more information forthcoming.

Detroit Free Press, July 20, 1938
It seems that by the following year the Stockholm Restaurant, a Swedish smörgåsbord (supposedly the first in Detroit), had taken residence there, and persisted until around 1962. In 1963 The Playboy Club opened its door and was a mainstay for a decade before moving to another location in the city.


The store seems to have persisted into at least the early 1980s but as an importer of rare goods, gifts and finery. Doris died in January of 1936, a few days short of her 40th birthday.

Detroit News, January 29, 1936


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

P. O. Surveying Detroit Needs

Detroit News , October 8, 1929 This is a long article about the Postal Service but our concern is with Arch Coleman, the first Assistant Postmaster-General, who recalled in his visit back to the town that he grew up in, that he was born in the house which was the first Yondotega Club at 302/518 East Jefferson. An article by the Free Press seemed to suggest that he was born nearby.

Yondotega Club Beginnings Told

Detroit Times , March 12, 1939 I will start this blog at the same point of introduction that I had to the Yondotega Club: this short snippet in the Detroit Times from March 12, 1939 that I dug up while researching the Sign of the Mermaid bookstore which opened in 1925 and was owned by Doris McMillan Pittman (later Hoover), daughter of William McMillan and granddaughter of Senator James McMillan. Not only had she reclaimed the home that she grew up in from obscurity but she revitalized and made it a profitable venture. Unfortunately for Doris, her eleven years of ownership came with widowhood, the accidental shooting death of her teenage son, a second marriage to her store manager Clayton Morse, Jr. that failed and ultimately her own untimely death in 1936. The Yondotega Club would have been afterthought to that very research had it not been for the fact that her father founded the club in that very house and her first husband, grandfather, uncle and business partner - Phelps Newberry...

The Ex-Libris Bookplates of James Frederic Joy and His Son Henry Bourne Joy

These are the ex-libris platesreally things found in volume (IV.) of Turner's History of England from 1830 featuring at least one Yondotega Club member: Henry Bourne Joy, who was the first president of the Lincoln Highway - which built roads from New York to San Francisco - and later became president of the Packard Motor Company. His father James Frederic Joy was a railroad magnate, friend of Abraham Lincoln and congressman from Michigan. To boot, there is a main road in Detroit and the western suburbs named after him (Joy Rd.). Besides the plates, the most interesting thing in the book is the marginalia, which I've yet to determine exactly whose it is. It would be great if it were one of the Joys but nearly a hundred years has passed between the latter's death so the likelihood is probably 50/50. Maybe not so ironically, I found this book at an estate sale just off of Joy Road (8634 Hazleton) in Dearborn Heights five years ago or so.